NewsNational News


Big question as Weinstein trial winds down: Will he testify?

Posted at 6:06 AM, Feb 11, 2020

Harvey Weinstein’s lawyers are set to rest their defense case Tuesday, but not before answering the big question looming over his New York City rape trial: Will he take the risk of testifying?

So far, they say, Weinstein hasn’t signaled he’ll roll the dice. His last chance to declare his testimony comes Tuesday.

As he left court Monday, the once-powerful Hollywood boss declined to answer a reporter who asked if he was going to take the stand.

Doing so could be risky because prosecutors would be able to grill Weinstein on cross-examination about heinous allegations that jurors already heard about in vivid detail from six of his accusers.

Weinstein, 67, is charged with raping a woman in a Manhattan hotel room in 2013 and forcibly performing oral sex in 2006 on a different woman: film and TV production assistant Mimi Haley.

Prosecutors called other accusers as witnesses as part of an effort to show he has used the same tactics to victimize many women over the years.

Weinstein has maintained any sexual encounters were consensual.

The Associated Press has a policy of not publishing the names of people who allege sexual assault without their consent. It is withholding the name of the woman accusing Weinstein of raping her in 2013 because it isn’t clear if she wishes to be identified publicly.

How Weinstein and his defense team feel the case is going could factor into his decision on whether to testify.

The trial has moved much more quickly than anyone involved expected. Jurors were initially told to expect six weeks of testimony. Now it’s on pace for closing arguments by the end of the week, with deliberations to follow.

If he declines to testify, the judge will instruct jurors not to view that decision as a sign of guilt.

“I am not a fan of blowing the lead if I feel like we are already on a road to victory,” said Brian McMonagle, a defense lawyer not involved in the case who helped secure a mistrial in Bill Cosby’s first sexual assault trial in 2017.

“In some cases, it is an easy decision because the client either can’t provide a credible explanation or you simply do not believe your client could survive cross examination because of any number or reasons.”

Weinstein has been increasingly upbeat coming and going from court as the trial has worn on, though in front of jurors the once-powerful movie mogul has mostly been sitting quietly at the defense table, munching on mints, jotting notes and occasionally dozing off.

On Monday, after strong testimony from a defense witness who repudiated the account of one of Weinstein’s accusers, his lawyer Arthur Aidala declared: “It was a great day for the defense today.”

Claudia Salinas, a Mexican model and actress, took the stand to defend herself against accuser Lauren Marie Young’s claim that she stood by and did nothing while Weinstein sexually assaulted Young at a Beverly Hills hotel in 2013.

“Never happened,” Salinas told jurors.

Young, a model, testified last week that Salinas closed the door behind her and Weinstein as they went into the bathroom, where she alleges he stripped off his clothes, grabbed her breast and masturbated.

Once it was over, Young said she found Salinas standing outside the bathroom and shot her an evil look before leaving as quickly as she could.

“If I had done that, I would remember that,” Salinas testified. “I would never close the door on anybody.”

Salinas took the witness stand as the defense called witnesses for a third day after more than two weeks of prosecution testimony.

In some other high-profile sex crimes cases, defendants have skipped testifying.

For example, Cosby did not take the witness stand either time he was tried for drugging and molesting a woman at his suburban Philadelphia home. The second trial, in 2018, resulted in the comedian’s conviction.

In another high-profile case, former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky was eager to testify at his 2012 child sexual abuse. But that was before his adopted son lodged allegations of abuse against him as the trial was going on. If Sandusky had testified, prosecutors could’ve then called the son as a rebuttal witness.

“I tell my clients once you take the stand you have lost your shield, which is me, and you are on your own,” said McMonagle, who was not involved in Sandusky case.

“In my experience as a prosecutor and defense attorney it is rare to see a client take the stand. The problem is, some jurors do hold that against you.”


On Twitter, follow Michael Sisak at and Tom Hays at