Are home warranties worth it? Woman furious after repair denied

BBB complaints pile up over warranty companies
Home repairs
Posted at 5:00 AM, Mar 28, 2022

Millions of Americans have a home warranty, paying on average $500 a year for peace of mind in case a major appliance stops working.

But thousands of them have filed complaints with the Better Business Bureau, claiming their warranty refused to pay when they needed it most.

Rosalie Battle is one of them. When her 16-year-old heat and air conditioning stopped working, she called her home warranty company.

She had been paying them $50 a month, more than $500 dollars a year for protection.

So they sent a repairman, who claimed it was a simple fix.

"He said it was a fuse," Battle said. But it wasn't. "Two hours later it went out again," she said.

So she called again, and the warranty company sent a second repairman, who this time diagnosed a blown heat exchanger.
But she was stunned by what the warranty company then told her.

"They told me they are not going to fix it because it's a manufacturer's defect. I said what's that got to do with me? I just need it fixed," she said.

The warranty company, however, told her the $1,000 repair did not qualify for coverage.

Thousands of complaints over repairs denied

Sarah Wetzel of the Better Business Bureau says consumers need to take caution if a warranty company says that everything is covered, because many have dozens of exclusions.

She says warranties can be a great deal if they actually cover the costs. But the Bureau has thousands of complaints concerning dozens of warranty companies.

To protect yourself, Wetzel says:

  • Read the fine print.
  • Specifically read the terms, conditions, and exclusions, to make sure that you fully understand what you're getting.
  • Find out if you can use your own repairperson, or have to use one chosen by the warranty company.
  • Read reviews of that company at the Better Business Bureau, where you can tell if there is a pattern of complaints.
  • Look over the whole contract before signing anything, for any red flags about things that won't be covered (such as a roof or appliance over a certain age).

Rosalie Battle ended up canceling her home warranty, saying it was not worth over $500 a year, if it would not cover a furnace and AC repair.

So do your homework first, so you don’t waste your money.


Don't Waste Your Money" is a registered trademark of Scripps Media, Inc. ("Scripps").

Like" John Matarese Money on Facebook

Follow John on Instagram @johnmataresemoney

Follow John on Twitter (@JohnMatarese)

For more consumer news and money saving advice, go to